Reviews For Winning the Cup
Name: Ser reviewed Resuming the game on Feb 14, 2005 10:04 am
I'm so glad that Ginny is willing to give Draco another chance. And I'm thrilled with the changes dear Draco is making. Obviously he's going to have to watch himself around Ginny and try not to come on too strongly. But I've got a feeling that they'll work it out. Ginny's forgiven him, and now they just need to work on building up their relationship face to face.
Name: Myanceris reviewed Resuming the game on Feb 14, 2005 08:32 am
Oh god, I'm addicted to this story. It's so emotionally wrangling and their pain is so wonderfully written that I can almost feel the angst. Great job. I'm really excited to hear that it's nearly finished. You know I'm rooting for a happy ending right? LOL

Myanceris
Name: applecede reviewed Resuming the game on Feb 14, 2005 02:23 am
I had such a fun time catching up on the updates I missed while I was away. I'm really enjoying this ride - I like the Blaise and Luna interactions, and I think Ginny's moving on was written perfectly - not rushed or unbelievable or anything, considering all that happened to her. The tape recorder idea was a great touch, and it just shows how much Draco loves her, that he would go through all that.
Name: Rainpuddle reviewed Resuming the game on Feb 13, 2005 04:40 pm
*huggles Draco* He is so close to what he wants, but he needs to step back and allow Gin to go at her own pace. He does realize that she'll spook easily if he comes on too strong. Someone (Blaise, Luna AND Narcissa) needs to impress upon him (strongly) that good things come to those who wait. He's almost there, but coming on too strong...she wants lunch not marriage. Maybe after she returns home for good... Please, please, please Draco don't fuck this up! This is about the rest of your life!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Name: meeaz reviewed Resuming the game on Feb 13, 2005 03:56 pm
oh holy crap, when i read the summary of the chapter, i had to re-read it b/c i thought i saw that draco makes another mistake. i was like noooooooooooo. lol. can't wait to see what is to come. this story is amazing and unique. and can i expect a blaise and luna romance on the horizon? update soon. xoxo, meeaz.
Name: rembrandt reviewed Resuming the game on Feb 13, 2005 03:29 pm
Excellent - another chapter! This story is wonderful, I don't really know what else to say. I'm absolutely tickled that things are getting better.
Name: EnchantedBelle reviewed Time Out on Feb 11, 2005 06:34 pm
Draco deserves that! And i'm glad you are punishing him. =] Poor Ginny though cuz she also has to be punished. Well I lkd this chapter and I liked how you had her send him a tape recorder. That was fantastic.
Name: LadyEndymion reviewed Time Out on Feb 11, 2005 09:16 am
sorry, that should have been, I could even hear the scratchy sounds of the recorder. Elise
Name: LadyEndymion reviewed Time Out on Feb 11, 2005 09:14 am
This reply with unfortunately be brief - as I'm at work at the moment, but there's so much I wanted to say about this chapter that I may add more later. Anyway, brilliant chapter - you have a talent for conveying emotions - so beautifully written - you portrayed both of their anguish without the hyperbole of sentimentality - I could never hear the scratchy sounds of the recorder The tape recorder scene was perfect and so true - written words can deceive and I liked the tie to the CoS Draco's anguish was just right and at least he admits what he is - This is one of my favortie d/g fic, by the way. Elise
Name: Myanceris reviewed Time Out on Feb 11, 2005 06:05 am
The more I read of this story the deeper I get sucked in. I am on the edge of my seat now! This is so angsty and well written that I can almost see the haggard and drawn Draco. Oh it's awful. I feel so bad for him - is that wrong? Perhaps I should be feeling bad for Ginny but I don't. Aren't I wicked? Ah well, we both seem to enjoy torturing our characters so I am eagerly awaiting the next installment. Draco's letter was heart-wrenching btw.

Myanceris
Name: ser reviewed Time Out on Feb 11, 2005 01:43 am
This has to be one of the most painful, emtional and perfectly in character stories I have ever read. And in a way that's a good thing; Because you've managed to catch the readers attention so well, and actually make them feel and experience what the characters themselves are feeling. You haven't made Draco into a simpering fool, but you have managed to capture his humanity at a point where we are torn between being furious with him, and yet at the same time feeling incredibly sorry for him. I'm glad that at this stage Ginny's still willing to give him a shot. But it's going to take a lot of effort and pain for him to win her trust. And I think you'll capture this as well as you've captured everything else in this story. I can't wait to see what Draco's response will be.
Name: Anise reviewed The Porskoff Ploy on Feb 10, 2005 05:13 pm
Okay, I HAVE to review this chapter too... ;) The choices you made here were exactly right, and so different from the way a lot of authors would have chosen to take it. The easy way would have been for Blaise and Narcissa to convince Ginny to let Draco come in and talk to her. Big crying forgiveness scene, oh-how-Draco's suffered because he thought she didn't love him, etc., etc. But that would have been WRONG!!!!, and I'm so glad you didn't do it. This is the way it had to be.
Name: Cal Princess 2008 reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 03:15 pm
Wow! I've really liked this story since I read the one-shot that inspired it, but I really enjoy the way Draco screwed himself over and actually has to TRY to fix it himself. I really can't wait to see how you bring the two together again.
Name: Anise reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 02:00 pm
Oh,and one more thing! I can't edit my review to add anything to it so I'll have to double-post. ;) Draco has suffered. No doubt about it. But I feel that he has to suffer in some meaningful way, some concrete way, to not only be sorry for what he did to Ginny but to understand it on the deepest possible level. Something has to HAPPEN to him (ponders possibilities... I don't know, maybe all of Ginny's brothers get together and pull his fingernails out with pliers?) NOT that this usually happens in real life after something like this, but hey, this is fiction, right? ;)

Author's Response: I've not been very good at responding to reviews, mostly because I'm having a hard enough time trying to update my story ... trying to make this story believable has been challenging. I did have to respond to this review however as Anise is definitely one of my favorite fanfiction writers along with Mynuet and Rainpuddle (and a lot of others - I'm addicted to D/G I admit). I'm feverishly awaiting the conclusion of Heavenly Creatures and the start of Man in Black and have been swept away by Bound. So your very kind words have meant a lot to me. I do read all of the reviews and am quite frankly astonished by the response to this story. I felt strongly at Chapter 4 that I had to reflect the character of Draco and in this story, he was hell bent on getting his own way, no matter what the cost. It's his punishment that the cost may be beyond what he ever imagined. Will there be more suffering in future? I think both of the characters are suffering, albeit in different ways.
Name: Anise reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 01:56 pm
I admit it-- at first I wasn't all that impressed with this story. Ho-hum, another "Ginny and Draco have great sex and end up together" fic... But you surprised me greatly. I can't think of another story that's surprised me as much, or impressed me as much with its genuine understanding of these characters. And you know that's an honest review, because I started out saying something less than nice! ;) ................................................... (that was an attempt to put some white space in this review, btw...) The funny thing about Draco Malfoy as a fanfic character is that everybody loves to write him, but he's probably the hardest character to write really well. It's easy to write the cliches, but the best fics don't shy away from the nastier aspects of his character, and that makes him VERY difficult to write as a sympathetic human being. Increasingly, what I'm seeing is EvilDeathEater!Draco who cackles insanely while he burns down Hogwarts, or something, but that's just as far from canon as fluffycottoncandy!Draco. You took a chance with your Draco that was AMAZINGLY brave (I don't dare to take my Draco that far, although he's pretty dark, too. But I dont' think I would even try to do what you're doing here. I would likely say, after something like that, "And then Draco fell off a cliff. Oh, and Grawp was strolling along and happened to fall off too, and landed on top of him. Ginny picked up the pieces with Millicent Bulstrode. The End.") But you dared to do it, and that's made this fic into an astonishingly complex piece of writing... and an emotional journey to read.
Name: Funnykido reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 11:53 am
Amazing, as usual. I love how this isn't just your run-of-the-mill D/G story. It's easy to sympathize with both at once. Very good, I can't wait to see what happens!
Name: EB_sirius_lives_on reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 11:13 am
damn...this is brilliant. please please please with a cherry on top please update soon!! It would be greatly appreciated. EB
Name: caps reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 10:04 am
You have captured both Draco and Ginny's emotions very vividly. I feel sorry for both of them. I get the impression that Ginny cares for Draco very much, and i am glad that she is giving him a chance. I anticipate that Draco has learned his lesson and the next time his temper gets out of control, memory of this event will allow him to reign his emotions in. You have done a great job with this chapter in initiating a tentative correspondence between the two.- It didn't appear forced, contrived or seem to occur too quickly. Can't wait for the next chapter Caps
Name: Eiri reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 09:42 am
This was heart-wrenchingly beautiful. I could see in your writing that Ginny really did love him and still does, but she can't trust him yet. The emotions conveyed in the letter and the tapre recording almost made me cry. Bravo! On another excellent segment to this tale.
Name: rembrandt reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 09:11 am
Great chapter, again! There is no way how I can tell you how great this story is. I can see how difficult it must be to write so much passionate drama, but all I can do is say, keep it up! Excellent writing - and I'm so glad Draco was given a chance!
Name: jchaser reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 07:54 am
So glad you updated! Thanks. Another great chapter...love the tape recorder idea so she can truly if his words are true.
Name: badum reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 07:52 am
Ooh I hate and love stories like this. You write it so well - but I hate wanting them to get back together. He shouldn't be able to win back his heart's desire - she shouldn't have to do anything more than perfect her castrating charms. But its Draco and Ginny and he's in pain and as awful as his actions are I still want them together. Ugh. How will they ever know things are ok again? How will Ginny ever make up for her (less awful but still hurtful actions of denying their relationship due to family pressure and fear - I mean the pre-date rape stuff. It seems that Draco's crime just overbalances her bad behavior and he'll never be able to call her on it now but she didn't deserve to be raped but Draco had my sympathy in the first part.
Name: burningdaylight reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 06:21 am
sniff, sigh, sob!! really a sad situation... but draco deserves all of it! please, pelase, please, please, update, update, update, update!!!
Name: Rainpuddle reviewed Time Out on Feb 10, 2005 05:50 am
At least it's a start. Draco can't ask for much more than that. It does have to give him some hope though that she at least read his words and found something there worth trying for. I think she loves him far more than she's willing to admit. I think that Draco will be on his best behavior from here on out because he's learned a very painful lesson in what happens when he gets out of control. Ginny is a brave, brave witch for even trying. *sniffles*

Author's Response: This is the hardest story I've written and considering my meager output, that probably isn't saying much. I think this would be a smutty little sequel to Catching the Snitch but the dark side of Draco seduced me.
Name: EB_sirius_lives_on reviewed The Porskoff Ploy on Feb 09, 2005 11:53 am
WHAT?!?!!? Where's the bloody rest of it?! Why arent you done yet!? I can't take this waiting...this is a bloody good story and i have to know how its going to end....PLEASE, PLEASE PLEASE, UPDATE SOON! I could bloody well go insane if you don't.
You must login (register) to review.